History Nebraska Blog

Tractor vs. Horses

By David L. Bristow, Editor


Which is more economical for a farmer, a tractor or a team of horses?

Ogallala, Neb., 1918. History Nebraska RG0716-34-5


In the early years of tractors, the answer wasn’t obvious to everyone. A series of tractor shows in the Midwest from 1913 to 1919 encouraged the growth of power farming in the United States. Reynold M. Wik writes about it in a 1983 Nebraska History article (PDF).

The earliest tractors used steam power…

This is a Buffalo-Pitts steam tractor and water wagon. The photo is undated, but the Buffalo-Pitts company (of Buffalo, N.Y.) sold their first steam traction engine in 1882. The big steam engines were too expensive for most farmers. Use of tractors expanded as gasoline engines became more powerful and affordable. Tractor manufacturers competed against horses for many years, as shown by this 1932 Farmall brochure:  

“Farmall Tractors Plowed at Less Than Half the Cost of Plowing with Horses,” reads the headline on the back side of the brochure (​History Nebraska RG3358AM-4-8). Here’s a detail that breaks down the costs:  

And here’s a photo of the tractor described in the brochure, location unknown:


(Posted 4/29/2010; updated 6/8/22)

Become a History Nebraska Member Today

Learn More